The Trancendental Engineers – Scientology: a Consensual Delusion Based on Science Fiction

Sci-Fi-Planets-421981 | The Transcendental Engineers | Hugh AD Spencer

Read online | Download as .pdf

This is a thesis from 1981, which earned its author a masters degree and it is still astonishingly relevant today.

Spencer’s thesis is that the distinctive culture and communal activities of Science Fiction fans allows adults to indulge in healthy imaginative play.

He contrasts this with L Ron Hubbard’s Scientology, which he argues has exploited  SF imagery and technological optimism to create an unhealthy fantasy world. After attending a “Star Trek” conference, the author observed how fans have created a consensual ‘virtual world’ around the franchise.

“Trekkers” frequently attend these events dressed in reproductions of costumes from the series, often assuming the identity of favourite characters. They have an encyclopaedic knowledge of  the “Star Trek” universe, enjoy discussing it with other enthusiasts, and  aspire to the utopian ideals that are a feature of the series  – a society in which science and technology has ended poverty and brought about peace and equality.

Spencer concludes that the world of SF Fandom (which includes “Trekker” conventions) represents a new cultural form that has been created from personal fantasy. It can appear bizarre – but only because it is unfamiliar (fans who follow teams of sportsmen also dress in team colours, follow particular players &c but few people find this behaviour curious).

Trekkers clearly see the fictional devices of  “Star trek” for what they are – they do not, for example attempt to teleport themselves to work in the morning. Scientologists, however, do believe that it is possible, here and now, to develop superhuman powers  (including telekinesis, telepathy and immunity to physical disease) and expend time effort and considerable money in their pursuit of these goals.

Unfortunately, the “technology” that Scientologists trust will bring about their dream is nothing more than pseudo-science, and their  project has more in common with Melanesian cargo cults. Scientologists have embraced magical thinking (presented to them by Hubbard under the guise of Science) and lost touch with reality.

There is much more to this thesis, which is well worth a close read.


2 thoughts on “The Trancendental Engineers – Scientology: a Consensual Delusion Based on Science Fiction

    • It is indeed.

      Andrew Blake (the ‘role-playing guru’ mentioned in these articles) was taking an very active role in manipulating his victims. He carefully stage-managed complex encounters between his victims. This must have required a lot of time and effort, and required obsessive attention to detail.

      As he did not seem to be in it for the money, his motive was probably the exercise of control over other people. He must have been ecstatic when he proved just how powerful he was by manipulating someone into walking from NY to Canada – and in in winter, too.

      L Ron Hubbard showed the same characteristic delight in using his position to manipulate others, and exploited it with casual cruelty.

      However, I suspect Blake was as deeply immersed in this fantasy world as his victims were. In contrast, Hubbard remained realistic enough, for long enough, to imprint his fantasies onto a money making bureaucracy. In this way, his malign influence has operated on thousands of people, not just a small group – and continues to do harm after his death.

      This is what fascinates me about Scientology – why some people elect (with apparent sincerity) to accept the crude fantasies it is based upon, and allow them to control their lives.

      Thanks for the link.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.